Board Thread:Wiki Discussion/@comment-31763506-20180626010448/@comment-2804:431:B701:3979:851F:95AC:D626:3A94-20180626172634

Lostone2 wrote: One thing tat still baffles me is to read recommendations for that Walkthrough, even with it being so outdated. I think the reason for that is that the dictational format of that walkthrough is desirable and the wiki lacks something like that.

The current walkthrough reads more like a guide, it is mostly focused on making sure the player doesn't get stuck while occasionally (and inconsistenly) giving some guidance on non-essential matters.

There is value in that, but for a player that is trying to get the most out of the game, their best chance while using the wiki is having like 5+ different tabs open at all times and carefully going over them to make sure they don't miss or mess up anything, and its not that difficult to screw up since so many pages are ordered differently (Investments and Relationship Points are displayed in the order they become available, Secrets and Collectibles are displayed in the order the map they are located in is introduced but not necessarily the order the secrets become available, Secret Stats is ordered in what I think is the variable ID). And sometimes useful information about the decisions just gets scattered in that cluster, i.e the other day I was trying to min-max the social score to help with my chapter 4 decisions but I had a hard time finding out what affected the Ambassador's evaluation during Govern Yhilin, I only ended up finding it in one of the items under the "Yhilin" variable.

I understand that a "True" walkthrough is impossible due to the unfinished state of the game, but people will still appreciate an alternative that is easy to follow but also more "complete" than the current walkthrough.

Also correct me if I'm wrong but, aside from the investment decisions, Rafael's walkthrough only starts being wack during Simon's route right? Maybe just hide/quarantine/get rid of that segment and re-title that walkthrough in a way that it doesn't get mixed up with the main walkthrough, but I dont agree with fazing it out with pre-reunion stuff having little in terms of thorough and concise guidance.