Board Thread:Wiki Discussion/@comment-29984007-20171228223854/@comment-29984007-20171230093347

Lostone2 wrote: The good news is that I understand better your proposals now. But I can't agree to move that many tables, I'm sorry to say. One shouldn't have to visit the Secret stats page to learn what to do with the House Jade halfling.

and put in the secrets and colletibles is a factual difference? that information needed to be placed in the walkthrough page, o pehraps in the quest page, not in a secret&secret page. but the jade sabotage score is a hidden variable, not a secret, jade sabotage score is more like the 'help the poor' score in the same game section.

To me is pretty much different. In my eyes, the segregation of the 3AW in its own page it's because the style has to be different and there is a lot of internal variables, switches and conditions that configure a highly variable playthrough. It was required to have a lot of detailed info to understand how you're faring. No other section of the game have so many different outcomes. And that is why a segregated guide makes sense: because the style is quite different that to describe a how to beat dungeon or what priorities you should have Governing Yhilin.

i totaly agree, but this can be traslate to the war hidden variable section, in the chapter four (for now) no one check is made for any counrty CD o the IKD Morale, instability or aramite front. all that are mute variable, heavly used in the war but ignored outside. a page can be long as needed, but the readablity of the page is a important factor, the war stats are a simply a huge block anyone skip if don't interessed in the war, but if one is interessed to the war should go to check the war walkthrough, the only real ecception is the arclent acc. but it can be fixed usign that system.

Have you thought that the list for Simon's stats will be probably get even longer? Most of the new developments in the new countries increase also Economy and/or Social scores and I don't think that this trend will change. And although it happens less with the Religion score, we don't know if that will eventually change. I don't understand why you're more worried about Chalice States than Yhilin for instance.

my preocupation is for putting many list to much long in the same page. like the war the country score is a themed ensemble a consisten collection of list. can be encapsulate and put in a external page without much strech, the manly difference compared to the simon score (social, economic, religion) is that scores are build over all the game and checked thoroughly many time and nearly all decision can change them, the countries score are changed near all the time with investmet, they don't have a huge impact before chapter four and the value are build verly slow (compared to the social/economic/religion). and for yhilin in the chapter four we go over the bulk of the change, but for the new country we are at the start of the work, this is only the fundation of the whole structure...

a page is only a box with a label, more order is alwasy better, put to much stuff inside ad the result is a messy container.